Cautions on using the screening kit for help diagnosing Avian Influenza patients

Dr. Rungrueng Kitphati
17 December 2006

 

      The rapid test or screening test kit, that used to basically analyze Influenza patients, uses the principle of analyzing the antigen of Influenza A and B from the excretion of the respiratory system of the suspected patients by immuno-chromatography or Enzyme Immuno Assay (EIA). The test kit yields the result rapidly with in 15 – 30 minutes. If the test results positive, it is most likely to believe that the patient is infected from an influenza virus. The data shows that the screening test kit has an approximately 75 percent sensitivity and approximately 90 percent specificity. By using this Influenza screening test kit for Avian Influenza test is for helping in primarily diagnosing only (not for diagnosing Avian Influenza virus infected patients) and is for helping in deciding whether the antiviral medication is needed. In the operational level, however, misunderstandings have often been found on that if the test result from the kit is negative, the certain patient is not infected by the Avian Influenza virus. Physicians or officers then mostly will not send the specimen to the laboratories of Department of Medical Sciences for testing as well as will not report the case according to the surveillance system. The substantial usage of the screening kit reveals that the kit has a very low sensitivity percentage for Avian Influenza virus. Although the result from using the screening test kit is negative, the surveillance report must be taking place. Moreover, if the patient has any severe symptom, attended physicians should prescribed an antiviral medication as necessary.

      The results from the coordinating system for laboratory testing and surveillance, Department of Medical Sciences, are illustrated in the following table:

      Table shows numbers of suspected patients in Avian Influenza surveillance system, numbers of Avian Influenza infected patients, numbers of Avian Influenza infected patients that had been tested using the screening test kit, and the sensitivity of the screening test kit, comparing before and after taking “How to have a quality in samples collecting and delivering” training for medical and health officer.

Process duration
Before the training
(1 Dec 03 – 31 Mar 04)
After the training
No. of suspected patients
610
4,417
No. of samples to be tested per one patient (range)
1-3
1-6
No. of Avian Influenza infected patient
12
13
No. of Avian Influenza infected patient that had been tested using the screening test kit
7
10
No. of Avian Influenza infected patient
with the positive test result
2
3
Sensitivity (in percentage)
28.6
30.0


This shows that the quality of the samples are better ( p = 0.02)


Note:

  1. The screening test kits used in Thailand are SD Bioline Influenza Antigen A/B, MT Promedt Consulting GmbH and Quickvue Influenza A+B test, Quidel.
  2. “How to have a quality in samples collecting and delivering” training for medical and health officer was held from 1 April – 31 August 2004.
  3. There was one Avian Influenza infected patient that had been given an antivirus (Tamiflu) for longer than 48 hours before the specimen was collected and the test result from the screening test kit was negative.

 
Main   |   Laboratory testing fees    |  Samples collecting |  á¨é§¢èÒÇ  |   Contact us